The US Inspires Dreams and China Gets Things Done: Gauging Global South Attachments to Major Powers with Evidence from Nigeria
Abstract
How do citizens in the Global South form attachments to major powers competing for influence in their communities? Existing research focuses primarily on elite-level strategic motives or on the local impact of particular interventions. We argue, instead, that major powers that engage in development initiatives in the Global South form distinct reputations over time and that subsequent interventions activate those reputational assets, with some spillover into other dimensions of appeal. Drawing on an original, three-arm survey experiment conducted in Lagos, Nigeria, we examine perceptions of China and the US across four dimensions: their development model, partnership quality, operational effectiveness, and cultural appeal. At baseline, the results underscore distinct reputational pillars: China's reputation for operational effectiveness and the US's enduring cultural appeal. Upon treatment, the funder's nationality alone moves preferences toward the sponsoring power, but the effects differ in scope. US-funded projects draw on a broad, abstract reservoir of cultural goodwill that lifts perceptions of the US on every dimension. Chinese-funded projects confirm citizens' belief that China delivers and, notably, also raise interest in China's cultural appeal. These findings suggest that the nationality of a funder is legible to citizens, that soft power is multidimensional, and that major powers take distinct paths to influence.
Project Characteristics and Preferences over Foreign-Funded Initiatives: Evidence from Nigeria
with
John McCauley.
Revise & Resubmit, Studies in Comparative International Development
Abstract
What drives local perceptions of foreign-funded projects? Existing research focuses primarily on the investing country behind a project and, increasingly, on the features of projects themselves. We argue that, in low-income settings, support for foreign-funded projects turns most importantly on whether people find those projects useful in their own lives, and less on which power funds them. We test this claim with a visual vignette survey experiment in Lagos, Nigeria, in which respondents rated projects that varied along four dimensions: size, usefulness, environmental impact, and the foreign funder (China or the US). The findings indicate that usefulness is by far the strongest correlate of favorable evaluations, followed by environmental harm. Random assignment of projects likewise shows that size alone does not generate support, and a large but unhelpful project earns markedly less support than a small but useful one. Conditional on these features, respondents judge Chinese- and US-funded projects by similar standards; a tendency for US-funded projects to be penalized more for environmental harm is suggestive but not statistically robust. These results suggest that narratives of major power competition in Africa may obscure the more practical concerns on which local support actually rests.
Do Road Networks Mitigate or Amplify the Spatial Heterogeneity of Urban Public Goods? Evidence from Nigeria
Mushixue Zhang, Ge Shi, Jiantao Shi, Xiuling Zhang, Wei Wang, Lihang Feng, and Chuang Chen. Revise & Resubmit, Symmetry
Abstract
Road networks are often assumed to improve equitable access to urban public facilities, but their influence on measured inequality remains unclear in data-limited African cities. This study examines how measured inequality in access to hospitals, schools, and places of worship changes when road-network impedance is introduced in Lagos, Kano, Ibadan, Abuja, and Port Harcourt, Nigeria. Using OpenStreetMap data on a 500 m grid, we first assess the unevenness of facility locations without roads and then compare nearest-facility accessibility under straight-line distance, network distance, and two modeled travel-time scenarios. Inequality and clustering are measured with the Gini coefficient and Global Moran's I at grid, city, and administrative-unit scales. Facility locations are already highly uneven before roads are considered, with Gini values of 0.53 to 0.84. Relative to straight-line distance, network distance lowers measured inequality in 13 of 15 city-facility combinations, whereas modeled network travel time raises it in 11 of 15. These changes are small, with mean Gini differences of −0.014 and +0.020, and not all are statistically significant. Grid-scale spatial clustering weakens in all 45 road-scenario comparisons, and 35 of these directions persist after aggregation to administrative units. These results suggest that road networks neither uniformly reduce nor uniformly amplify inequality in access; the outcome depends on how travel cost is measured and on the scale of analysis. Accessibility assessments should therefore compare several impedance definitions and scales and treat the results as potential accessibility until population-weighted, locally calibrated travel data are available.